
I knew it! Except you didn't.
I could probably write a whole book on words of phrases I don't like, from redundant portmanteaus (guesstimate) to new expressions that should never have been allowed to exist (no homo). But for now, I have to discuss an old classic that gives me language indigestion.
"I knew it" is a flexible little guy. Like a cockroach or tumour it finds ways to exist anywhere at any time. What the phrase does which is both brilliant and annoying. It allows the speaker to retroactively use details from their memory to argue that they knew a recently discovered fact all along. I know. That's a pretty wordy phrase for a guy halfway done a general arts degree. But I can explain through an example.
"... and it turns out that Ashley was actually gay all along."
"I knew it!"
"What do you mean?"
"Well- she used to always wear converse shoes in high school. It's a lesbian thing."
When it comes to homosexuality, "I knew it" comes up way too often. Whenever someone comes out of the closet, there's always a person who claims they knew it all along. The thing is, they didn't. There's a big difference between having a suspicion and knowing something. If you saw Ashley making out with a girl at a gay club one year ago, sure. Then you knew it. But if you noticed her wearing questionable shoes, you certainly didn't know anything. Except maybe how to identify shoes.
There are some grey areas where I believe the phrase is acceptable. Sometimes if there are unsurprising repetitive outcomes to an ongoing subject, then "I knew it" can be justified to an extent.
"... so we all thought that this was going to work out. It was Ashley's third time in rehab. But the progress she was making was promising. But then, out of the blue during group therapy, she used a chair to smash open a window, and ran away into the night."
"I knew it."
"How so?"
"Ashley never changes. This is her third time in rehab after all. She has consistently not stuck to quitting drugs for ten years."
While it's not perfect, I wouldn't call it incorrect usage of the phrase, although "I'm not surprised" would have be a safer choice. The thing that the speaker knew, was Ashley's qualities that have remained consistent, unchanging and previously confirmed. This new circumstance is a logical continuation to Ashley's ongoing habits.
So the next time Ashley does something surprising or out of the ordinary, carefully consider what you say next.
Note: these rules also apply to people not named Ashley










